Stakeholder engagement at a Brownfield sitePosted: 05/19/2010
Last year I moved to Cranston, RI, to live with my mother-in-law, while my wife and I looked for a house. Until yesterday, I had no idea that just over one mile away, just across the city line, a heavily contaminated, 37-acre plot of land was being developed by the City of Providence. The site, formerly a Gorham Manufacturing Co. Silver Plant, is in tough shape, and the community that lives around it, in an area called the Reservoir Triangle, is currently in a stakeholder engagement over the remediation and development on the site.
Last week, most of the residents invited representatives from the City of Providence, the RI Department of Environmental Management (RIDEM), and Textron, Inc. to a meeting at Alvarez High School, which was hastily built on a parcel of the site a few years ago. Textron, Inc. bought the silver manufacturing plant in 1967, and later sold it to a Private Equity Group. After a few attempts at development a second Equity owner went bankrupt and the City of Providence foreclosed on the property in 1990.
The development has four parcels. Alvarez High School was built on one, without the necessary approval of remediation by RIDEM. On the second parcel, a retail plaza was built, featuring a Stop & Shop store as its anchor tenant; Stop & Shop hastily closed the store in 2006, without public comment, but apparently because of issues with VOC in the soil below. The other two parcels surround a cove that Gorham used to dump waste from its operations. Chemical solvents like trichloroethylene (TCE) and perchloroethylene (PCE), which were used to clean machine parts, seeped into the land and the cove. The cove, part of Mashapaug Pond, shows high levels of heavy metals such as lead and compounds such as dioxins and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, making it unsafe to eat fish from the pond, swim or come into direct contact with the water or soil at the bottom of the pond.
The residents are working with the Environmental Justice League of Rhode Island, and the recent meeting followed two years of silence from the responsible parties. In fact, in April 2008 the residents sent a letter to Mantec Engineering and Consulting, which represents Textron, and complained that the remediation plans were insufficient. The following paragraph about the former Stop & Shop Complex reflects the nature of the dialogue:
“This Super Stop & Shop facility… has been abandoned since October of 2006. Since neither the City of Providence, the landlord, nor Kimco Realty Trust, the present lease holder, or Stop & Shop Corporation, the previous tenant have made any effort to inform the community and the public as to the disposition of the property, we will assume the indoor air conditions at the facility have been a health risk since its opening in 2006, and continue to be an issue of major concern since the store has not been reopened, having been hastily abandoned by Stop & Shop in late 2006 without warning. Apparently the building cannot be used (even for commercial purposes) until remediation has been implemented and completed. Remediation which Mantec and Textron Inc aggressively insisted was unnecessary and unwarranted three short years ago.”
At last weeks meeting, the residents apparently subjected the representatives to what reporter Frank Carini described as an “interrogation.” The land next to the high school has not been remediated, and uncovered debris sits only 20 yards away, separated only by a chain link fence. No signs exist to warn neighbors to remain away from the contaminated land. After looking at the history of documents, this case reminds me of other cases in New England where old manufacturing facilities are hesitant to accept blame and remediate after decades old pollution and its after-effects are discovered. Textron appears to have been evasive with local residents.
The planned developments on the former site reek of poor planning. The YMCA owns one of the parcels, and had planned to develop it until it remained unremediated; now there are tentative plans to build some ball fields for the high school. As of now, the high school is still in use, but the retail development is mostly abandoned. The only remediation that has occurred in fact, was court ordered removal of a slag pile from the Pond. The one part of the communication that stands out to me is the sophistication of the resident group, together with the EJLRI staff. They are doing everything they can to hold Textron’s feet to the fire. A Brownfield development specialist recommended the site as a Superfund candidate, and that is probably an appropriate solution.